Re: [asa] High School Genius & Her Science Project

From: PvM <>
Date: Mon May 28 2007 - 18:33:36 EDT

Indeed, it shows how America indeed has abandoned reason. Just for example

Farther into the movie, Al explains the greenhouse gas effect. He
presents a graphic that shows the sun's rays heating the Earth's
surface resulting in infrared rays going from the Earth's surface and
back into space. His graphic suggests that some of the outgoing
radiation is reflected from the top of the atmosphere and back to
Earth. This idea is the basis of anthropogenic (man made) global
warming theory.

This is the idea of the green house effect, global warming is just a
green house effect which is increasing in strength

 He fails to mention that this effect has never been measured, only
calculated, and by scientists on one side of the debate. This is one
of the most hotly debated issues in the global warming debate.

I doubt that few scientists are denying the existence of the green
house effect. It is in fact not really a hotly discussed issue.

Not only does this issue involve complicated theoretical quantum
physics, but water vapor absorbs infrared radiation. As is often the
case in global warming presentations, he forgets that water vapor is
by far the most abundant greenhouse gas; 3 to 4 percent of the
atmosphere. And this is important because at most, man-made greenhouse
gases are 1/ 10,000 of Earth's atmosphere.

You must be kidding... Complicated theoretical quantum physics to
explain the green house effect? And yes, water is a major greenhouse
effect, I wonder what the relevance of this is.

I wonder if Janice really wants such ignorance to be shared with
others without a fair warning?

Sad to see how high school kids are being misled by 'pseudo science',
no wonder the US is in such a bad shape. Scary...

Thanks for sharing Janice, let this be a warning to all of us who are
tempted to rely on bad science to make their case.
On 5/28/07, Janice Matchett <> wrote:
> This is a good one to pass on far and wide! ~ Janice
> 05/27/07
> Al Gore: Fisked By A High School Genius
> I have a masters degree and a total of 60 hours of grad study under my
> belt. I have 38 years experience in the mental health field and a fairly
> good understanding of science and the scientific method. Woody and I have
> written over 50 posts on the Global Warming issue, some serious, some
> humorous. I have read countless articles on global warming, both in the
> scientific literature (both pro and con) and in various blogs (both pro and
> con). Woody and I have jousted with GWTBs (Global Warming True Believers) in
> numerous posts and a number of different blogs. And yet, never, NEVER, NEVER
> NEVER have I come across such a delightful and factual fisking of OWLGORE
> and his Inconvienent Truth than a young lady doing a high school science
> project which she posted on the internet.
> If you don't do anything else this week, read this excellent post and
> ponder the intellect that must be behind it. Kristen Byrnes, you will go far
> young lady.
> Ponder the Maunder

To unsubscribe, send a message to with
"unsubscribe asa" (no quotes) as the body of the message.
Received on Mon May 28 18:34:10 2007

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Mon May 28 2007 - 18:34:14 EDT