RE: High School Bible class attacked

From: Donald Perrett (E-mail) <>
Date: Wed Aug 03 2005 - 03:24:13 EDT

While I personally don't see the necessity for biblical study in public
schools, seeing as it can be obtained in church or private schools, I also
don't see the alarmist reaction as being helpful. The course is not
"forced" on anyone even by the anti-YEC admissions. It is an elective. If
a majority of parents want this course to be available to their children so
be it. It high time for the rest of the population to stay out of other
peoples homes. School districts are supposed to be able to customize their
curriculum to the needs of their local population, while abiding by national
standards. If we got to a point where those in New England can dictate
curriculum in the Southwest then the question becomes can the YECs dictate
what should be taught in New England? If a local district wants to put more
emphasis on math does anyone object? No. It's only objection to a view
which others do not hold that becomes controversial. So basically one must
first admit that they are flawed logically and cannot withstand someone
else's views. Being closed minded is what got the YECs to where they are.
Why should we join them in being closed minded? Let them have their field
day believing that they have gained a victory. So long as it is an
elective, "I" can decide whether my child will attend it or not. "I'm" not
being forced.

Even better, use the same amount of effort to get course electives into
school that would teach proper science from a Christian perspective. Then
perhaps everyone will win.

Don P

-----Original Message-----
From: []On
Behalf Of Carol or John Burgeson
Sent: Tuesday, August 02, 2005 18:20
Subject: High School Bible class attacked

From the AP: (in part)

Aug. 1, 2005, 5:01PM

Clergy group attacks Bible study course in schools

Associated Press

AUSTIN A religious watchdog group went on the attack today against a
Bible study course taught in hundreds of schools in Texas and across the
country, complaining it pushes students toward conservative Protestant
viewpoints and violates religious freedom.

The Texas Freedom Network, which includes clergy of several faiths, said
the course offered by the Greensboro, N.C.-based National Council on
Bible Curriculum in Public Schools is full of errors and dubious research
that promote a fundamentalist Christian view.

The National Council on Bible Curriculum Web site says its elective
course is offered in high schools and junior highs by more than 300
school districts in 37 states.

Texas Freedom Network President Kathy Miller said her group looked at the
course after the Odessa school board voted in April to offer the class.
It asked Southern Methodist University professor and biblical scholar
Mark A. Chancey to review the class curriculum. Miller said Chancey was
not paid for his work.

Chancey's review found the Bible is characterized as inspired by God,
discussions of science are based on the claims of biblical creationists,
Jesus is referred to as fulfilling Old Testament prophecy and
archaeological findings are erroneously used to support claims of the
Bible's historical accuracy. He said the course suggests the Bible,
instead of the Constitution, be considered the nation's founding

All of those points may be acceptable to some religions, but not to
others, Chancey said.

His review also found the curriculum relies on many nonacademic sources
and directs teachers and students to sectarian Web sites and research
materials. In other areas, entire pages or chapters appears to be lifted
from other publications without proper sourcing, Chancey said.

"No public school student should have to have a particular religious
belief forced upon them," the Rev. Ragan Courtney, pastor of The
Sanctuary, a Baptist congregation in Austin.
------- end AP article ---
Note particularly the phrase "...discussions of science are based on the
claims of biblical creationists. . . "

And yet, some folks still think the YECs have not won.

Today and tomorrow, Kathy Miller and Dr. Mark Chancey will appear on the
following national news programs (all times Central):

Today, Aug. 2
4:30 p.m. ABC News Now
6:00 p.m. Hardball with Chris Matthews (MSNBC)

Wednesday, Aug. 3
11:00 a.m. MSNBC Connected Coast-to-Coast

Burgy (Review of THE ANONYMOUS GOD)

Received on Wed, 3 Aug 2005 03:24:13 -0400

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Wed Aug 03 2005 - 03:27:49 EDT