Re: Response to Howard on Tillich & Bultmann

From: Howard J. Van Till (
Date: Thu May 22 2003 - 11:53:27 EDT

  • Next message: Debbie Mann: "RE: Response to Howard on Tillich & Bultmann"

    From: Dick Fischer <>

    > Can we allow for any supernatural divine action? A resurrection certainly
    > seems to call for something extraordinary.

    You and I will each make our own choice on such matters.

    > Not to be divisive, but would you care to give any NT example (outside the
    > resurrection) where "supernatural divine action" might explain the event,
    > such as calling forth Lazarus, changing water into wine, a blind man made
    > whole, etc.

    Unfortunately, we have no empirical access to any of these events. All we
    have is a set of narratives, most of them written decades after the events
    under scrutiny, narratives whose primary purpose is religious, not to
    provide simple matter-of-fact chronicles. That, coupled with our limited
    familiarity with the cultural context and the literary conventions of
    religious literature of that day, opens the door to the vast diversity of
    interpretations now on the table. You and I (and others on this list) will
    reach differing conclusions on how best to understand these narratives. I
    accept that.

    Howard Van Till

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.4 : Thu May 22 2003 - 12:24:40 EDT