Re: Thorough Humiliation of Bible "scholars"

From: Jan de Koning (
Date: Thu Oct 24 2002 - 11:31:40 EDT

  • Next message: Stuart d Kirkley: "Re: Celebrating Creation.II"

    At 10:48 AM 20/10/2002 +0000, Jim Eisele wrote:
    >Hi Jan,
    >I am very sorry about your uncle. My mom once gave me the
    >definition of history as a record of man's inhumanity to man.
    >Obviously, my post was not a personal attack.
    >It was intended to be a commentary on the incredible amounts of
    >garbage that I have been discovering recently in the name of
    >I hate to say it, but scholarship has it's biases. This is a
    >generalization, but liberal scholarship doesn't take the Bible
    >seriously enough. Conservative scholarship, um, is arrogant.

    In reply:

    I agree with most of what you wrote. As a member of a synodical study
    committee I studied these issues. Our report to the Christian Reformed
    Synod 1991,pages 367-430. Our conclusion was that Gen. chapters 1 - 11,
    were not history in the modern sense of the word. They are more like a
    general introduction.

    Generally speaking, the Bible tells us history, yes, but history-telling in
    Old Israel (and for that matter in old Western Europe) is not the same as
    scholarly researching and telling of history.

    My uncle concluded on the basis of the biblical texts and the reading of
    the El-Amarna tablets (he read both in the original as far as they were
    available) that the Israelites entered Canaan in 1380 BC. However, I
    personally believe that the date was not that important.

    For me that book was important, since I was in High School and my uncle
    quoted my geography teacher. So, I read through the book to see where and
    when and if he was quoted more than once. I learned a lot about Israel's
    entering Canada, and got high marks in geography, because I could
    "intelligently" talk with my teacher, even without studying
    geography. That is where my interest in the early OT stories started.


    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.4 : Thu Oct 24 2002 - 15:15:39 EDT