RE: Why YEC?

From: Stephen J. Krogh (
Date: Sun Aug 19 2001 - 23:50:19 EDT

  • Next message: Lucy Masters: "Why YEC?"

    That would be great if you could provide the name to verify that this letter
    is not a hoax, made in an attempt to validate YECism. This is a little
    reminiscent of Harold Hill and the longest day hoax letter.

    Stephen J. Krogh, P.G.
    The PanTerra Group

      -----Original Message-----
      From: []On
    Behalf Of Allen Roy
      Sent: Sunday, August 19, 2001 6:34 PM
      Subject: Why YEC?

      I got this from a YEC email list. I thought It might spark an interesting
    discussion. The person's name has be removed to protect his identity. If
    you (singular) absolutely must know who this is, I'll talk to the author and
    see if his is willing to be identified to you.

        ----- Original Message -----
        Sent: Friday, August 17, 2001 9:02 PM
        Subject: Why YEC?

        Hi everyone,
              Several people have answered the basic question "Why did you
        YEC?" These are interesting, and I'll add my answer.

              When I was in school in the 30's and early 40's, I had never heard
        anyone with an interest in science who actually believed early Genesis.
        was raised in church, and believed the Bible (except for early Genesis).
        my church was liberal and I hadn't become a born-again Christian. Since
        had an active interest in science, I believed in evolution and ancient
        Earth-age. That belief was reinforced when the Army put me in the
        Project (first atomic bomb) and I met a number of scientists whose names
        you've all heard of.

              Later, while I was Chief Engineer of Isotopes Inc., several of our
        staff were Ph.D.'s, including one who was also Professor of Geochemistry
        Columbia University. He and a few others were Wheaton graduates, and
        Christians who believed in Progressive Creation. We often had lunch
        together, and the subject of origins was one of our favorite "arguing
        points." By that time I had become a born again Christian, and studied
        Bible. But I still never heard of any scientist who accepted the YEC
        viewpoint, so I didn't either.

              But I asked many questions, about radioactivity, dating methods,
        This Professor was generally recognized as one of the world's experts on
        geochronology, gave testimony before Congress on that subject, and was
    also a
        true gentleman who tried to answer my queries honestly. He and another
        believed fervently in OEC and progressive creation over extreme times.
        questions kept getting back to "Well how do you really know?" on
        aspects of the foundations of radio-dating. Our lunchtime group wasn't
        a bunch of dummies -- we were all quite knowledgeable about dating
        etc -- that was one of our company's products. But I kept feeling
        doubts about the foundational accuracy of radio-dating. (BTW, this was
        the years around 1960.)

              I kept studying technical journals and books, and finally became
        convinced that circular logic and faith in prior beliefs played a strong
        in radio-dating -- in other words, it wasn't a "scientific fact,
    provable by
        scientific methods." There was too much unprovable belief involved. By
        time I was a dedicated Christian, who kept being bothered by this
        of my own beliefs. I became open to a YEC attitude, but still had never
        known there was such a thing as a "scientific creationist" who believed
        YEC. When I finally met one, and he gave me one of the early copies of
        Bible-Science Newsletter, I found there was actually such a thing as a
        scientist who really believed in early Genesis. I subscribed, and
        became an active scientific creationist -- (that was the common term in
        days, and I still don't like that term).

              When someone asks me why I'm YEC now, one facet of my answer
        includes the closer relationship to God the Creator, and the comfort
        gives. No, you don't have to believe in YEC to be a Christian, but it
        certainly does help one's relationship with God.

    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sun Aug 19 2001 - 23:50:52 EDT