----- Original Message -----
To: <email@example.com>; <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Cc: <email@example.com>; <firstname.lastname@example.org>; <email@example.com>
Sent: Tuesday, August 14, 2001 11:23 AM
Subject: Re: Is Jonah to be taken literally?
> In a message dated 8/13/01 8:40:09 PM, firstname.lastname@example.org writes:
> << I tried to make the point in a recent post that the primary reason for
> considering Jonah not to be an historical narrative is the literary
> the book. It contains obvious exaggerations. >>
> Let me weigh into this discussion. The exaggerations are obvious. The
> is in the class of stories, such as, Irish tall tales. It is told in this
> form, I believe, to catch the attention of the people of Israel who were
> known not listen to a straight sermon. A good story can do more to
> an attitude than other didactic literary devices.
> It is not enough, however, to call it a parable or tall tale or myth. We
> need to ask about its purpose. Why was the story written, and why was it
> preserved? With the help of others I have come to believe that the book
> written to correct the unhealthy ethnocentricity of the Jewish people, who
> had wrapped themselves in the belief that God loved them alone to the
> exclusion of other nations. Here God tells his people that he is
> about even the wicked city of Nineveh.
> Moreover, it hints at the point made in Isaiah, that the Jews were to be a
> light to the Gentiles, and that they, like Jonah were running away from
> George Murphy pointed out to me that Jonah may be seen as a counterbalance
> the book of Nahum, which gloats over the destruction of Nineveh. In Jonah
> find God having a tender spot in his heart for even the cattle there. By
> picking the most extreme cases--the most wicked city and ignorant people
> lowly animals--the story makes the point that God's concern extends to all
> lesser cities and creatures as well.
> Why did Jesus refer to Jonah to confirm that he will rise again in three
> if Jonah was not a historical character? I suggest that Jonah was so well
> fixed in the collective consciousness of the Jews, with all the nuances of
> the story, that Jesus had to say no more. Just as we might say, "As honest
> Old Abe," and everyone would get the point, so Jesus' meaning was clear to
> Hope this helps.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue Aug 14 2001 - 09:19:02 EDT