> Fair enough. A year or so ago you asked if I would address the paper by
> Robert Gastaldo: A CASE AGAINST PELAGOCHTHONY: THE UNTENABILITY OF
> CARBONIFEROUS ARBORESCENT LYCOPOD-DOMINATED FLOATING PEAT MATS. In
> response to your request, I did so
> (see http://www.calvin.edu/archive/asa/199805/0119.html).
> I can't recall that you ever commented on my critique. Was that because
> you agree with me and see where Gastaldo's arguments fail? If not,
> please point out where I was wrong.
I didn't bother because Keith Miller jumped in and you and he had long
discussions about coal formation (and Keith knows a lot more about it than
-- Steven H. Schimmrich Assistant professor of geology Department of Geology and Geography firstname.lastname@example.org (office) Calvin College email@example.com (home) 3201 Burton Street SE 616-957-7053, 616-957-6501 (fax) Grand Rapids, Michigan 49546 http://home.earthlink.net/~schimmrich/