I agree. If I may speak personally and perhaps leave myself open to attack
in any future debate where I want to appear certain, I find myself
constantly in this dilemma. One the one hand I mistrust deeply the
certainty of modernistic scientism. On the other hand I fear the danger of
falling into the postmodern morass. I fear the morass because I believe
there are realities to be certain about, including the God who has revealed
himself to us with sufficient clarity for us to truly know him. And I
mistrust modernistic scientism with all it owes to Hume, not least because
it seems to be so arrogant and certain in its defiance of that God.
I guess many of struggle at just this point.